• Lab
  • AndroidForMobile Foundation at
    HOME
              
    LATEST STORY
    Bad news from Mashable, BuzzFeed, and Vice shows times are rough for ad-supported digital media
    ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
    March 28, 2014, 10:21 a.m.

    This Week in Review: Reasons for optimism about journalism, and how far to take traffic-chasing

    Plus: Facebook’s bet on virtual reality, Netflix and AT&T’s net neutrality debate, and the rest of this week’s news in journalism and tech.

    This week’s essential reads: If  you only have a minute, the most important reads this week are the overview of Pew’s , Deadspin’s Tim Marchman on the , and the Tow Center’s Alexander Howard in historical context. 

    Reasons for optimism about the news industry: The Pew Research Journalism Project’s annual smorgasbord of data about the news industry, the report, was released this week, and after several gloomy years, the report had a this year. The headlining figure, as CNN’s Brian Stelter , was Pew’s tally of 5,000 new journalism jobs created at more than 400 digital news startups, in addition to into news-related digital media startups in 2013.

    Pew’s president, Alan Murray, from the report, including its findings of increasing news consumption on mobile devices and social media, and Pete Cashmore of Mashable the growing efforts to make news more accessible and mobile.

    USA Today’s Rem Rieder also for journalism’s online growth, though he expressed concern about the future of local journalism. The Knight Foundation’s Eric Newton said of the new work that’s being done in local journalism and shouldn’t be left out of studies like this. The Washington Post’s Paul Farhi into local journalism’s long decline, pointing out that “the biggest investments in digital news have gone toward start-up ventures that target broad and borderless audiences, bypassing community news altogether.”

    There was plenty of bad news in the report, too, and Digiday’s Lucia Moses of some of it: The new revenue is only a sliver of journalism’s total funding, which still remains heavily dependent on advertising. And the 5,000 new jobs are a long way from replacing the jobs that have been lost. Poynter’s Rick Edmonds that despite its decline, the newspaper industry still accounts for more than half of the news business’ revenues.

    TV news — whether local, cable, or network — earns far less revenue, as Edmonds pointed out. Pew’s numbers were particularly dire for MSNBC, as and pointed out. The Lab’s Justin Ellis highlighted the year of ownership upheaval in the local TV news industry, as well as the growth of online video. Poynter’s Sam Kirkland noted that , though the audience for online news videos is remarkably young. And Patrick Seitz of Investor’s Business Daily in young people’s news consumption habits.

    traffic-cc

    Debating the merits of chasing traffic: The move toward a more nakedly traffic-driven orientation has been in the works in online news for a long time, but the Advance-owned Oregonian in Portland may have taken it to new levels among traditional news organizations. The alt-weekly Willamette Week  that require Oregonian reporters to post new articles three times a day and post the first comment on any substantial post. Annual bonuses will be based on performance ratings, which will be determined in large part on web metrics.

    The Columbia Journalism Review’s Ryan Chittum  as a brazen institutionalization of the “hamster wheel” mentality that has overtaken journalism, saying it makes it much more difficult for The Oregonian’s reporters to do good, serious work. “The sad thing about Advance’s digital forced march is that its executives really think they’re getting ahead of the curve. But they’re implementing 2008’s conventional wisdom in 2014, and they’re doing it badly at that,” Chittum wrote. Mathew Ingram of Gigaom  and likely to lead to clickbait, but said he liked the focus on engagement, producing lots of regular content, and a variety of posting styles.

    The Lab’s Joshua Benton said he’s not so much concerned about the particulars of The Oregonian’s bet on online traffic as the fact that it’s making a bet in the first place. Any bet, he said, is an encouraging departure from the age-old plan of cutting, retrenching around declining print advertising and circulation, and relying on an aging audience.

    The New York Times’  included The Oregonian’s changes as an example of a larger trend toward paying journalists based on the traffic they bring in, a practice that brings a welcome meritocracy to journalistic production but is also alarmingly open to manipulation. Newswhip’s Paul Quigley  that this trend actually tilts things toward writers’ favor rather than their bosses, because it depends in part on their brands and their networks. Gigaom’s Ingram noted, though, that  as long as advertising (and, by extension, advertisers) are still driving the bus of online revenue.

    Lucia Moses of Digiday  among online news organizations to giving journalists metrics, and Poynter’s Sam Kirkland  that there are still lines editors won’t cross in search of traffic. Deadspin’s Tim Marchman  in the ubiquitous term clickbait, saying it presents a moralistic “false binary between stories that serve the public interest and those cynically presented just because people will read them.”

    oculus-rift-vr-cc

    Facebook jumps into virtual reality: Facebook made another big-dollar, out-of-left-field purchase this week, buying two-year-old startup Oculus Rift, which makes virtual reality headgear, for $2 billion. Recode’s Kara Swisher reported some details on , and Time’s Lev Grossman on Oculus’ background and what sets it apart.

    Virtual reality, of course, wouldn’t seem to be a natural extension of Facebook’s existing platform, so many people have been wondering exactly what the social network has in mind. Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg said he and then move toward providing a broader range of virtual experiences with friends. Andrew Wallenstein of Variety said, though, that Facebook’s .

    Several other observers said Zuckerberg doesn’t really know what Facebook’s going to do with Oculus; he’s simply hedging his bets on the technology of the future. Said venture capitalist : “The next thing was mobile. Mobile is now the last thing. And all of these big tech companies are looking for the next thing to make sure they don’t miss it.”

    Reuters’ Felix Salmon , hedging his bets in all kinds of fields against the eventual decline of Facebook as a social media platform. Gigaom founder Om Malik said the is that we’re moving toward a glass ceiling for the advertising-based model. Forbes’ Eric Mack , meanwhile, that Zuckerberg will have a tough time turning virtual reality into a mainstream technology.

    Oculus raised its initial $2.4 million through Kickstarter, and its backers there were not exhilarated at the company’s big payday, but outraged, as The Verge’s Adrianne Jeffries . Minecraft creator Markus Persson said he , and Dean Putney of BoingBoing of people who thought Oculus could be a “next big thing” that was actually powered by the grassroots, rather than corporations. PandoDaily’s James Robinson said , and other new technologies are likely to follow: “An entire generation of hardware innovation is up for grabs right now, and neither Facebook or Google seem about to close their wallets.”

    Net neutrality and streaming video: The net neutrality debate was stoked again late last week by a pair of posts from two of the players with the biggest stakes in the game. Netflix’s Reed Hastings , saying that Internet service providers are charging content providers for interconnection (like in the last month) just because they can. AT&T’s Jim Cicconi that users’ increasing appetite for streaming video (that is, Netflix) has huge costs for ISPs, and that Netflix wants those costs to be borne by all broadband customers, rather than the ones who are streaming the video through Netflix.

    Supporters fell in on both sides: BoingBoing’s Cory Doctorow “extortion,” and the New America Foundation’s Sarah Morris to police the opaque world of interconnection in which the Netflixes and AT&Ts of the world negotiate. On the other side, StreamingMedia’s Dan Rayburn said about the situation it’s actually in, and Forbes’ Mark Rogowsky said the net neutrality Netflix is calling for .

    The Verge’s Ben Popper in light of Hastings’ post, and Gigaom’s Janko Roettgers that Netflix should become a peer-to-peer network would actually work.

    Meanwhile, The Wall Street Journal that Apple and Comcast are in talks about a deal that would use an Apple set-top box for streaming TV and allow Apple to bypass online data congestion through an interconnectivity arrangement. There was a lot of skepticism about the story, with Variety’s , Gigaom’s , and StreamingMedia’s all throwing cold water on it.

    Reading roundup: Several other noteworthy stories from this busy week:

    — After weeks of hints, The New York Times officially two new paid-content options, an $8-a-month app of core Times content called NYT Now and a $45-a-month subscription called Times Premier that includes behind-the-scenes information about the paper. Poynter’s Sam Kirkland has , BuzzFeed’s Charlie Warzel looked at , and Gigaom’s Mathew Ingram for personalizing the Times’ paid content plans.

    — Turkey’s government sought to ban Twitter late last week, prompting widespread workarounds by Turkish Twitter users as well as a . One Turkish court on Wednesday, while another one . The government also on Thursday. Some of the best commentary on the subject has been by Turkish digital sociology professor Zeynep Tufekci, who explained and .

    — The chatter about Nate Silver’s relaunched data journalism site FiveThirtyEight continued this week, and while much of it come from an between and New York Times columnist , some of it was also quite thought-provoking. The Tow Center’s Alexander Howard to some of the backlash against data journalism, Om Malik to Silver on dealing with criticism, the Columbia Journalism Review’s Tanveer Ali called for at FiveThirtyEight, and Adam Tinworth offered a .

    — The New York Times that the Obama administration is proposing an end to the U.S. National Security Agency’s systematic collection of Americans’ bulk phone records, allowing it access to phone companies’ data only with a specific court order. The Volokh Conspiracy’s Stewart Baker to Congress’ proposed overhaul, and The Intercept’s Glenn Greenwald  the new plan may put pro-NSA Democrats in.

    — Finally, tech blogger Ben Thompson on the well-trod topic of traditional and future business models for news, and the Lab’s Joshua Benton added some of his thoughts on what might be ahead.

    Photos of Bangkok traffic by and Oculus Rift by used under a Creative Commons license.

    POSTED     March 28, 2014, 10:21 a.m.
    SHARE THIS STORY
       
    Show comments  
    Show tags
     
    Join the 45,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
    Bad news from Mashable, BuzzFeed, and Vice shows times are rough for ad-supported digital media
    The rapid growth of Google and Facebook continues to take its toll on digital media companies.
    Asking members to support its journalism (no prizes, no swag), The Guardian raises more reader revenue than ad dollars
    The Guardian revamped its ask and its membership offerings — moving from 12,000 members in the beginning of 2016 to 300,000 today.
    Beating the 404 death knell: Singapore news startups struggle to cover costs and find their footing
    Political news reporting doesn’t seem to be holding up well as a business in the city-state. And it’s even harder when you’re seen as “alternative” media.