• Lab
  • AndroidForMobile Foundation at
    Just showing our work isn’t enough
    ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
    Oct. 26, 2012, 11:10 a.m.

    This Week in Review: The new iPad mini and Surface tablets, and a BBC scandal hits the Times

    Plus: Newsweek’s demise and magazines’ future, possible newspaper targets for Rupert Murdoch, and the rest of the week’s media and tech news.

    Two entrants into the tablet market: We got a first look this week at two new devices that should play a big role in shaping the tablet market going forward. The first, the iPad mini, was unveiled at an Apple event which also included announcements of a new iPad, Macbook, iMac, Mac Mini, and . BuzzFeed has the of all of Apple’s shiny new toys, and Macstories has a pretty good in particular, while Engadget to its 7-inch tablet competitors.

    Reaction from market analysts (rounded up well in this ) was generally pretty positive, though tech writers were a bit more skeptical. Several of them noted that Apple has ripped the 7-inch size in the past, with Fast Company’s Mark Wilson that the iPad mini is simply market defense from Apple, rather than its typical iconic product. Likewise, Slate’s Farhad Manjoo for getting updated products out so quickly but wondered why Apple’s getting into the 7-inch tablet market in the first place, and whether people will pay a premium for a type of device whose chief virtue so far has been its cheapness.

    But Reuters’ Felix Salmon said Apple  about its 7-inch competition, because its customers are deciding not which 7-inch tablet to buy, but which iPad to buy. Zach Seward of Quartz reported that Apple will primarily , as a device that can comfortably fit inside a handbag. Meanwhile, Poynter’s Jeff Sonderman said if the 7-inch size mimics the phone experience, the tablet experience, or is something new altogether.

    The second device that made a debut this week was Microsoft’s Surface tablet, which arrives at the opposite end of the tablet market — not somewhere between a phone and tablet, like the iPad mini, but between a tablet and a laptop. Reviews on the whole (summarized by The Guardian) were pretty negative for Surface. A few highlights: TechCrunch’s Matt Burns said it’s , but a PC (for a post-PC world). The Verge’s Joshua Topolsky , “If this device is not as good as (or better than) the best tablet, and not a complete alternative to a laptop — who is this for? What is it supposed to be?”

    Gizmodo’s Sam Biddle said Surface of a tablet that’s truly oriented toward getting work done, but isn’t there yet. And in a positive review, Wired’s Mat Honan said Surface is the first tablet that you could .

    BBC’s abuse scandal crosses the Atlantic: The BBC is finding itself engulfed in a child sexual abuse scandal, and the fallout has reached across the Atlantic to The New York Times. The scandal — which surrounds deceased former BBC host Jimmy Savile, who is accused of sexually abusing hundreds of girls — has been buzzed about for weeks in the British press.

    Poynter’s Andrew Beaujon has a on the case, and The New York Times has a to it, but here’s the gist: An investigative report into Savile by the BBC program Newsnight was killed late last year, and Newsnight editor Peter Rippon’s  this month explaining why was called inaccurate by the BBC. This prompted Rippon to this week, as the BBC’s investigative program Panorama also ran a  examining Savile’s behavior and the decision to kill the Newsnight report, including the that it was dropped based on pressure from BBC higher-ups. Meanwhile, BBC director general George Entwistle was by Parliament this week and also that the BBC is investigating up to 10 other serious sexual abuse allegations against other employees.

    So what does this have to do with The New York Times? Well, Entwistle’s predecessor as BBC chief, Mark Thompson, is about to take over as the Times’ CEO. Thompson reiterated to Times reporters that until after it had been killed, as Times public editor Margaret Sullivan that “it’s worth considering now whether he is the right person for the job, given this turn of events” and urged for tough Times coverage of the issue.

    Times publisher Arthur Sulzberger Jr. for Thompson, but Sullivan’s questions raised considerable attention from British outlets such as and , as well as praise from GigaOM’s . Thompson, for his part, said he from the Times and the BBC, though Reuters’ Jack Shafer said he in the scandal even if he had nothing to do with killing the Newsnight program.

    Is there hope for magazines? The commentary surrounding Newsweek’s announcement last week that it would drop its print edition continued to spill over into this week. Barry Diller, whose IAC owns Newsweek, told analysts that , but that he’d try to make them as spare as possible. There was a bit more optimism about Newsweek’s online-only prospects, as several people offered up possible models for what it might look like as a web publication: The Atlantic from the , U.S. News & World Report by , and Gourmet from .

    The postmortems on Newsweek and its fellow newsweeklies also continued. Michael Learmonth of Ad Age argued that far from complementing Newsweek, , saying, “What TDB and its ilk offer — original writing from a few big names mixed with aggregation-with-attitude — turns out for many readers to be a just-good-enough substitute to a newsweekly.” At Vanity Fair, Jim Kelly that Newsweek fell in part because its audience is no longer looking for institutional, authoritative voices on culture and politics.

    The Columbia Journalism Review’s and Ad Age’s both argued that magazines aren’t doing nearly as bad as they’re made out to be. Magazines and online publishers are facing the same difficult ad market, Dumenco said, but magazines have to turn real revenues, rather than simply relying on venture capital. Reuters’ Felix Salmon that magazines may be better than startups at throwing off profits, but they’re still a risk, and “the uncertainties of digital ultimately trump the storied legacy of print.” Meanwhile, a couple of other magazines made some digital-centric changes: Time to the mobile-oriented responsive design, and MIT Technology Review as a “digital first” publication.

    New newspaper prospects for Murdoch: The Tribune Co. is about to emerge from bankruptcy, and one of the buyers looking at its two biggest newspapers, The Los Angeles Times and The Chicago Tribune, is Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp., according to a . News Corp. . Jeff John Roberts of paidContent that buying the Times and Tribune wouldn’t make much business sense for News Corp., despite the economy of scale they would provide alongside The Wall Street Journal. Murdoch would need to add revenue streams in a hurry with those papers due to the impending spinoff of News Corp.’s news properties, Roberts wrote.

    At the Lab, Ken Doctor argued the opposite — News Corp.’s coming news/entertainment split makes it easier to buy those papers, not harder. With it, he said, Murdoch can go back to focusing on acquiring papers as political capital, as he’s done for decades, and the bankruptcy offers a bargain-basement price. Elsewhere on the News Corp. front: There are now allegations that its papers weren’t the only ones involved in hacking people’s phones — against papers from its rival, Trinity Mirror.

    Reading roundup: Here’s what else has been going on in media and tech this week:

    — The New York Times Co. for the last quarter stemming from , prompting a steep drop in its stock price. GigaOM’s Mathew Ingram , and paidContent’s Jeff John Roberts about its future.

    — A few political media notes as we near the home stretch of the American election season: At The New York Times, Thomas Edsall that Mitt Romney could be paving the way for secrecy (especially toward the press) to become the norm in presidential campaigns. President Obama’s campaign of an off-the-record conversation with The Des Moines Register editors after they publicly complained that they wouldn’t allow the talk to be on the record, though The Washington Post’s Erik Wemple was . And Poynter’s Amanda Hess on reporting on memes.

    — Norwegian media commentator Martin Bekkelund  who had all of her Amazon Kindle books deleted by Amazon without warning or, really, explanation. Simon Phipps  (she bought a Kindle in one country and ended up transferring the account to another Kindle she bought in another country). Amazon restored her ebooks, but not before BoingBoing’s , Techdirt’s , and GigaOM’s  condemned its actions.

    — Poynter held a workshop in New York this week on digital ethics; you can see of it on Poynter’s site. Social media researcher Danah Boyd on fear in an attention economy in essay form on Poynter, and Craigslist founder Craig Newmark . Forbes’ Jeff Bercovici , and GigaOM’s Mathew Ingram also .

    — Finally, a couple of interesting Pew studies released in the last week: One on , and one on .

    Photo from used under a Creative Commons license.

    POSTED     Oct. 26, 2012, 11:10 a.m.
    Join the 50,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
    Just showing our work isn’t enough
    “There’s very little current demand for the majority of reproducible code from newsroom leadership or the general audience.”
    Let’s talk about power (yours)
    “If we don’t use it in ways that give people quality news, useful information and power, people will find a way around us.”
    Newsrooms take the comments sections back from platforms
    “Local news organizations should become a driving force for better online public discourse, because Facebook and Twitter aren’t cutting it.”